Tobacco taxation: the misleading argument of illicit trade

The tobacco industry regularly claims that increasing taxes on cigarettes would encourage illicit trade and lead to losses in government revenue. However, scientific evidence and international experience show that it is possible to increase tobacco taxes while simultaneously reducing illicit trade.

Illicit trade is not primarily driven by taxes

Illicit tobacco trade is a serious public health problem. It makes cheap cigarettes more accessible, reduces tax revenues and can fuel criminal networks. However, contrary to the tobacco industry’s claims, its scale is not primarily determined by tax levels. Effective customs controls, anti-corruption measures, product tracking and tracing by independent bodies, and sanctions all play a decisive role. Countries such as the United Kingdom and Canada have successfully increased tobacco taxes while reducing illicit trade.

An industry that has itself fuelled smuggling

Although tobacco manufacturers now present themselves as partners in the fight against illicit trade, their historical involvement in smuggling networks is well documented. Research based on internal industry documents and several legal proceedings has highlighted the role of major multinational tobacco companies in these practices.

The illicit trade argument primarily serves the industry’s economic interests: it allows tobacco companies to oppose a particularly effective public health measure. Indeed, increasing tobacco taxes reduces tobacco consumption, especially among young people, while also increasing government revenue.

In Switzerland, hundreds of millions in additional tax revenue

Projections by the Swiss Federal Council also contradict the industry’s arguments. With a total tax burden reaching 75% of the retail price of cigarettes, additional tax revenues could reach CHF 645 million per year, despite an expected 26% decrease in consumption and an assumed doubling of the share of untaxed cigarettes, particularly those purchased abroad. Switzerland therefore does not have to choose between effective tobacco taxation and combating illicit trade. It must act on both fronts: regularly and substantially increase tobacco taxes while strengthening controls, independent tracking and tracing systems, and international cooperation.